Godwin, Morris, Laurenzi & Bloomfield, P.C.

Union Rule Requiring Photo ID In Person to Resign in RTW State Upheld by NLRB ALJ

 

 

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Labor News Up To The Minute

by   Samuel Morris               Godwin Morris Laurenzi Bloomfield

50 N. Front St., Memphis TN  38103

901 528 1702    901 949 1144

 

established yesterday - subscriptions good until tomorrow - published as news breaks

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

IBEW Rule Requiring Photo ID to Resign Upheld by NLRB Judge

 

The NLRB has been opposing union rules which make it difficult for union members to resign their membership and withdraw dues deduction authorizations. In Sulkowski v. UAW, 07-CB-140311, NLRB Region 7 issued a complaint against the UAW for requiring members to resign in person, with proper identification, and then not effectuating the resignation until these procedures had been met. After Region 7 issued a complaint, the UAW settled.

The Board also brought an action against the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) Local 58 over a new rule requiring members to present a photo ID and a written request in person at the Union Hall on the grounds that the rule on its face violates the National Labor Relations Act. The Board argued that the rule violated Section 8(b)(1)(A) which bars labor unions from restraining or coercing employees in the exercise of NLRA rights.

However, Board ALJ David I. Goldman rejected the argument of the NLRB General Counsel finding that the rule was merely a "facially noncoercive" procedure which did not violate Section 8(b)(1)(A).

In October 2014, IBEW Local 58 announced its new policy claiming that it "has had experiences in the past where members have lost their membership through fraudulently submitted paperwork." The local implemented the new rule that "any member that desires to opt out of membership or dues deduction must do so in person at the Union Hall of IBEW Local 58 and show picture identification with a corresponding written request specifically indicating the intent of the member."  If appearing at the Union Hall "poses an undue hardship [the member] may make other arrangements that verify the identification of the member by contacting the Union Hall."

While upholding that policy as facially lawful, Goldman also suggested that he is skeptical that a union could lawfully reject any resignation that doesn't follow the procedure. The general counsel's case attacked the policy as unlawful on its face, and no witnesses were produced who had been prevented from resigning.  Goldman noted that lack of direct evidence and stated he was not deciding whether either provision can lawfully be enforced against a member.

The case, Local 58, Electrical Workers (Paramount Indus., Inc.), 2015 BL 351259, NLRB ALJ, No. 7-CB-149555, 10/26/15, arose in Michigan, a Right to Work State.  A copy of the ALJ's decision is available at  

http://www.btlaborrelations.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Administrative-Law-Judges-Decision.pdf

 

 

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

-----all the labor news that's not fit to print anywhere else----

To sign up contact smorris@union-law.com

 

50 N. Front St., Memphis TN  38103

901 528 1702    901 949 1144

 

Union Rule Requiring Photo ID In Person to Resign in RTW State Upheld by NLRB ALJ

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Contact Our Law Offices

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Address

Godwin, Morris, Laurenzi & Bloomfield, P.C.
50 North Front Street
Suite 800
Memphis, TN 38103

Toll Free: 888-508-7939
Phone: 901-236-0578
Fax: 901-528-0246
Memphis Law Office Map

Review Us

Phone